I made this game up based on the eye color riddle.
You will need
- At least 6 players, preferably between 10 and 20
- Coloured headbands – about 5 of each colour, and more than the total number of players, so for a group of 12 players it would be good to have 5 red, 5 blue, 5 yellow and 5 green, for example.
- An opaque bag
Aim of the game
Identify the color of your headband.
How to play
Place all the headbands into a bag, and ask each player to close their eyes, remove a headband, and place it on their head, before opening their eyes. Every player is allowed to see the color of any other player’s headband except their own. Everyone knows how many headbands of each color there were at the start, but not what is left in the bag.
All players sit in a circle and the first player makes a statement about how many headbands they see, for example:
I see one red headband
The next player now has a choice, they can increase the number of the headbands by one, or the change the colour, for example:
I see two red headbands
or
I see one green headband
Play continues around the circle either increasing the number or changing the color. Players are not able to decrease the number even if they change the color.
If at any point a player believes that the statement a player has made is not true they are able to challenge it. The player who made the statement must then identify the players who have those colour headbands. If they are correct then the person who made the incorrect challenge is eliminated. If the statement was false then the person who made it is eliminated.
When a player’s headband is revealed via a challenge then they must all return it to the bag and draw another. After a challenge the game begins at the start, without the player who was eliminated.
If a play feels that it is impossible to make a true statement according to the rules above then they have the option to make a statement about two colours, for example:
I see four red headbands and three blue headbands
This has never happened when I have played the game as someone always wins before this point.
How to win
At any point during the game any player is able to shout “stop”, and announce the colour of their headband. When they do this they remove the headband from their head. If they are correct they have won the game. If they are incorrect they are out of the game.
Now the total number of headbands is reduced so the game play begins again with the player to the left of the player who announced their colour making a true statement about how many headbands of a certain colour they see.
Gameplay
This game can be quite short, so it probably makes sense to always begin the statement of the number of headbands at one.
Like The Jack of Hearts this game has the benefit of allowing players to remain in the game for as long as they choose, or eliminate themselves at any point, simply by guessing their headband colour.
Strategy
It is usually possible to deduct the colour of your own headband quite quickly once you understand how it’s done. This might mean that the game can’t be played many times by the same people, but I’ve never had the chance to play it more than once with the same group anyway, so I’m not sure.